Skip to content

Why the internet sometimes feels fake

Bots and repetitive content can make the web feel strange, but I don't want suspicion to become my default response to everyone.

planted June 19, 2026 · last tended November 9, 2026

A captured spark. Unverified, unpolished, possibly wrong.


Some comment sections leave me wondering whether anyone is actually talking to anyone else. There are repeated compliments, oddly generic replies, and accounts that seem to turn up everywhere with roughly the same thing to say.

That feeling is often described through Dead Internet Theory: the idea that much of what we see online is automated activity rather than people interacting. I understand why the idea is appealing, but the feeling alone can’t tell us how much of a particular feed is automated.

As someone learning cybersecurity, I don’t find the existence of bots surprising. Automated accounts and content farms are familiar parts of the web. Generative AI adds another way to produce large amounts of plausible material, which is one reason I’ve been thinking about how much effort it takes to find something useful.

What I want to be careful about is the next step, where noticing some automation becomes assuming that anything slightly awkward must have been produced by a machine.

When suspicion starts doing the work

People repeat phrases, leave generic comments, and write in polished or unusual ways for all sorts of reasons. A tidy sentence isn’t evidence of a bot, and a typo isn’t evidence of a human.

The idea of apophenia, or finding meaningful patterns where the evidence doesn’t support them, is relevant here. Once I’m expecting to find fake accounts, it’s easy to fit ambiguous details into that expectation.

I don’t think that makes every suspicion unreasonable. It means I should distinguish between “this feels odd” and “I have enough evidence to say what happened”. The first can be a reason to look more closely without turning into the second.

Seeing something often isn’t the same as checking it

There’s another issue that bothers me more than whether any individual reply is automated. If I keep encountering the same claim, I can start to feel as though it’s common knowledge, even when all the repetitions might come from the same source.

Research on the illusory truth effect explores how repetition can make statements seem more believable. That doesn’t mean people automatically accept everything they see repeatedly, but it gives me a reason to check where a familiar claim came from.

Several posts agreeing with each other aren’t necessarily several independent pieces of evidence. They might all be repeating one account, or borrowing the same explanation without checking it.

What I can actually do with that

I’d like to get into the habit of following important claims back to their source and being more comfortable leaving a question unanswered when I can’t verify it. That’s especially useful when the alternative is sharing something because it fits what I already suspect.

It also helps to remember why I wanted to be online in the first place: to learn things and hear from people. Treating every unfamiliar person as a possible bot would make that experience pretty miserable.

Paying attention to how I reach a conclusion won’t solve the problem of synthetic content, but it can help me avoid adding to it. Sometimes the most accurate thing I can say about a strange comment section is that I don’t know what’s going on there.

Paths that lead here

Where this note points

More from these beds