Learning to explain things better
Someone told me I wasn't a good explainer, and it made me think about how often I talk past people.
A captured spark. Unverified, unpolished, possibly wrong.
Someone told me recently that I’m a bad explainer, and my first instinct was to argue with them. That probably tells you something about how the conversation was going.
After sitting with it for a while, I could see what they meant. When I care about a subject, I want to include everything that makes it interesting to me. I start explaining the background, remember an exception, add another example, and eventually realise I’ve given someone a much longer answer than they asked for.
From my side, it feels like enthusiasm. From theirs, it can feel like being talked at, or being treated as though they don’t know anything. I don’t think meaning well gets me out of paying attention to how that lands.
What I’m assuming when I explain
The curse of knowledge is a useful way to think about part of this. Once I know something, it can be difficult to remember which steps weren’t obvious before I learned it. I hear the connections in my own explanation because I already know where I’m going.
Elizabeth Newton’s study of people tapping out songs is a good illustration. The person tapping has the tune in mind, while the listener only hears the taps. It’s easy for the tapper to overestimate how much of the song they’re communicating.
I recognise that gap when I explain technical ideas. I might use a word that seems ordinary to me, then build the rest of the explanation on it without checking whether we mean the same thing. Adding more detail won’t necessarily help if the confusing part was in the first sentence.
It can happen in the other direction too. Sometimes I explain background the other person already knows, which leaves them waiting for the answer they actually wanted. Guessing their level more confidently isn’t much of a solution.
Leaving room for the other person
I’d like to get better at asking where to start. Something as simple as “Have you come across this before?” or “Would a quick example help?” gives the other person a chance to shape the conversation.
After that, I can explain one part and pause long enough for them to respond. If they ask about an earlier step, that’s useful information about my explanation. If they’re already comfortable with it, we can move on without working through every detail I prepared.
Grice’s maxim of quantity is relevant here: contribute as much information as the conversation needs. I like it as a reminder because I often act as though a more complete answer must be a better answer, even when it makes the conversation harder to follow.
I’ve also been thinking about Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development, which concerns what a learner can do with support beyond what they can currently do alone. I’m using that as a broad reminder to meet someone where they are, rather than assuming I can work out the right level without listening to them.
None of these ideas gives me a script that works for everyone. They do give me a reason to pay attention to the response I’m getting and adjust as we go. That’s a practical use of watching how I’m thinking while I’m talking.
Why I care about this
I’d like to be a university lecturer someday, and I want students to feel they can ask a question without being buried under the answer. That seems like a skill I should practise well before I’m standing in front of a class.
It also matters in ordinary conversations with friends. They shouldn’t need to interrupt a lecture just because they asked what I’ve been working on.
The worry underneath all this is familiar: I don’t want sounding knowledgeable to become more important than being understood. For now, I’m trying to notice when I’ve answered the question and give the other person a chance to decide whether they want more.
Paths that lead here
- Worrying about sounding smart · This is also where learning to explain things to another person helps.
Where this note points
- Getting comfortable sharing my thoughts · I'm trying to make room for mistakes without letting the fear of them stop me from publishing.
- Worrying about sounding smart · I sometimes worry that I've learned the vocabulary of an idea before I've really understood it.
More from these beds
- Making time for the life I want · When studying security starts to feel overwhelming, I end up thinking about what else I want to make room for.
- Why I keep rereading sentences · I'm trying to understand what makes reading difficult for me, without treating every slow paragraph as a personal failure.
- Why the internet sometimes feels fake · Bots and repetitive content can make the web feel strange, but I don't want suspicion to become my default response to everyone.
- The Unchosen Here · On the unsettling mystery of being this particular consciousness.